Tag Archives: vatican

Pope Leo’s Hypocrisy on Immigration

Vatican City operates one of the strictest immigration and access regimes in Europe.

Entry is heavily controlled with unrestricted public access limited mainly to St. Peter’s Square and certain basilica areas during designated times. Most of the territory requires permits for entry, especially non-public zones. Unauthorized entry, especially by bypassing security, violence, threats, deception, or in groups/vehicles, is treated as a serious crime.

Penalties for illegal entry run between $10,200–$25,700, plus prison terms of 1–4 years. Convictions can include a ban from Vatican territory for up to 15 years (with further prison time for violations). Aggravating factors (e.g., using firearms, disguises, or multiple people) increase penalties.

Citizenship and residency are extremely limited.

Only clergy, Swiss Guard, officials who are working in Vatican City may apply for temporary residency, which is revoked when the job ends. There is no general path for economic migrants, family reunification, or asylum seekers to settle permanently.

In short, the Vatican City State enforces its borders rigorously to protect its security, sanctity, and limited capacity, which is in keeping with Catholic social teaching regarding states having the right to regulate immigration for the common good.

Christian cartoonist and pundit, Gary Varvel, weighs in –

A scene we’d like to see

Pope Leo XIV has been busy clutching his pearls over the Trump administration’s mass deportation efforts, labeling them “inhuman treatment”—because apparently, a sovereign nation enforcing its borders is now a sin. This is just the latest entry in the Pope’s ongoing “Political Activist of the Year” campaign against the President.

The hypocrisy reached a fever pitch late last year when Leo decided to play the “Pro-Life Gatekeeper.” He rebuked Catholic politicians who support hard-line immigration policies. His logic? “Someone who says ‘I’m against abortion’ but I’m in agreement with the inhuman treatment of immigrants… I don’t know if that’s pro-life.”

Bad theology

Equating the termination of a life in the womb with the deportation of an illegal alien is a feat of unscholarly theological gymnastics. To lecture the United States for conducting immigration raids while safely ensconced behind the Great Wall of Vatican City is hypocritical, to say the least. If the Pope wants to preach about open borders, he can start by unlocking his own.

If the Pope is so deeply distressed by the plight of illegal aliens leaving the U.S., there’s a simple, holy solution: Trump should just charter a few flights and drop them off at the Vatican. Since the Pope is so eager to welcome the world, let’s see how many cots he can fit between the frescoes of the Sistine Chapel.

1 Comment

Filed under Loose Pollen

Pontifical Hypocrisy

Pope Francis has released another scolding to American Trump supporters. In it he says, “I have followed closely the major crisis that is taking place in the United States with the initiation of a program of mass deportations.” Then he equates migration with necessity, as if all the millions who came here illegally did so to escape persecution. Clearly, he has not followed our open border crisis closely.

He claims that “the rightly formed conscience cannot fail to make a critical judgment and express its disagreement with any measure that tacitly or explicitly identifies the illegal status of some migrants with criminality.” Sorry, but no. A criminal is someone who has committed a crime. A crime is an unlawful act punishable by a state or other authority. Entering any locale in a manner that violates their law is a crime. What is hard about this? The United States has procedures for those who genuinely need to flee persecution. Those who follow them are genuine migrants. Those who sneak in are criminals as are those who have been denied asylum, yet have stayed anyway.

Pope Francis is a hypocrite. Although Vatican City does not require visitors to produce a passport or have a visa to visit, it does not permit overnight stays. And of the few areas that are open to visitors, most require an entrance fee and/or have a dress code. If you break the Vatican’s laws, its highly trained and well armed law enforcers will deal with you.

Just three weeks ago, Vatican City announced increased penalties for those who violate its borders:

  1. These sanctions apply especially to those who enter with expired permits, who do not meet the established requirements, who bypass border controls or security systems, or who enter by means of violence, threats, or deception.
  2. Penalties can be increased if the crime is committed with firearms, corrosive substances, by a person in disguise, or by several people together. Likewise, if illegal access is made in a vehicle, the penalty can increase by up to two-thirds.
  3. Anyone convicted of illegal entry will be banned from entering Vatican territory for a period of up to 15 years. If this sanction is breached, the offender may be punished with a prison sentence of one to five years.

Sources

Comments Off on Pontifical Hypocrisy

Filed under Loose Pollen